In fact, she says she disagrees with Petersons position. He said he thinks ideologues are using unsuspecting and sometimes complicit members of the so-called transgender community to push their ideological vanguard forward., The fact that its potentially illegal for me not to participate in that is something that I think is absolutely dreadful, he said. Shepherd supporters attending the rally on Wilfrid Lauriers campus, November 24, 2017. Others claimed it was an erosion of free speech. Even then, ambiguous about free speech. VILE: Paris Hilton says she has frozen 20 boys via IVF as she waits for a girl, Rosary-wearing Jill Biden promotes contraception to Kenyas young people, US govt data reveals shocking miscarriage, still birth rates after COVID jab compared to flu vaccine, Canadian pastor forcibly removed from drag queen story time for kids vows to keep protesting, Epstein-linked Clinton aides suspicious death ruled suicide despite being tied to tree, shot in chest. Joel said Shepherd was in violation of Lauriers gender and sexual violence policy. LAURIER Universityhasapologised after audio was leaked of staff members interrogating a teaching assistant for presenting both sides of an argument about gender pronouns. Youve silenced them because theyre now not willing to say what they wanted to say., Jordan Peterson tweeted his support for the student. Its terrible that this sort of thing is happening, he says in an interview. They are young Conservatives from Laurier and the University of Waterloo. Several faculty members and students reached out and asked to comment via questions over email and under the condition of anonymityboth requests were denied and interviews never took place.). He warned from the outset it would lead to compelled speech and declared he would refuse to use gender neutral pronouns, and neologisms such as ze and zir, even though Bill C-16 bans discrimination based on gender identity and expression. Such criticism has grown with some of Shepherds comments on Twitter, from thanking former Rebel Media personality Faith Goldy for her coverage at the Laurier counter-protest, to Shepherd explaining perhaps shes getting more support than Khan, the Dalhousie student, regarding free speech because I didnt make contemptuous and insolent comments about white tears and white fragility. The Rainbow Centre continues to demand an apology from President MacLatchy for refusing to acknowledge the existence of transphobia on campus. They say they are acting in a non-partisan capacity today, inviting people from all political ideologies to join, but are quick to point out their disappointment that young Liberals declined their invitation to be on the speakers list. At the dinner table, the family discussed things like biological determinism versus free will, Jennifer says. Theyre being handed signs that read I stand with Lindsay #freespeech.. Free speech is a great idea and equality is a great idea, but we cant have those conversations when people are not able to be present.. Im open to whether that was the right decision or not because theres a cultural aspect to television., Instead, most of Lindsays spare time was spent reading, everything fromArchiecomics to Christopher Hitchens. Over the next week, every major newspaper in the country had opinion-editorials offering every possible take on Shepherds case. Having problems signing this? She grabs her pen and starts writing about the state of free speech on university campuses and about the experience of being labelled a transphobe. Lindsay Shepherd wishes she had written her speech last night. When he circulated amongst his colleagues to sign, however, he says only about 50 per cent of them said they would. People are scared. Neither knew one student from the class would soon contact the Rainbow Centre, the campus LGBTQ support community, to complain about the discussion. She doubts shell ever see a copy of it, even if shell be the principle subject. log in. Students have come to us feeling complicated, upset and invalidated, Hewson says. Leibold isnt sure if the complaint to the professor about Shepherd opening up this discussion came from someone in his tutorial, but if it did, he says he wouldnt be surprised. He later added, This is precisely why I opposed Bill C-16.. We werent sure what was going to happen.. But for me thats the spirit of the university is challenging ideas you already have, she replies. I have no concept of how many people complained What their complaint was You havent shown me the complaint., I understand that this is upsetting, says the assistant professor, but there are also confidentiality matters, The academics and administrators remarks reveal that they believe Shepherd has perpetrated a hate crime against transgendered students. I should have seen how meeting with a panel of three people would be an intimidating situation and not invite a productive discussion, he said. Those who do speak are being extra careful with their words. She was trying to make the point that it influences people a great deal.. Bill C-16, which became law in June 2017, added gender expression and gender identity to Canadas Human Rights Code and to the Criminal Codes hate crime section. We had to wash it, clean it, and recycle it, says Mahdi Ghodsi. According to LifeSite News, Adria Joel, the university's acting manager of its "Gendered Violence Prevention and Support" office, told Shepherd that she caused "harm and violence" to the transgender community by not denouncing the inappropriateness of Peterson's discriminatory views. Shes very principled, he says. Even the day of the free speech rally Finn was advised by colleagues not to come to campus. TA Lindsay Shepherd is surrounded by advocates for freedom of speech on campus before delivering a letter to the University President's office at Wilfrid Laurier University on November 24, 2017. Faculty at Laurier took sides. As a result, Shepherd was called in by her supervisor Nathan Rambukkana, Professor Herbert Pimlott and Adria Joel, the university's manager of gendered violence prevention. It is legal in Ontario for someone to record a conversation without the knowledge of all parties if the recorder is one of them. The free speech proponents, meanwhile, have redoubled demands that the administration adopt the Chicago Principles. So bringing something like that up in class, not critically., It was critical, Shepherd interrupts. What I have a problem with is, I didnt target anybody, says Shepherd. I am a multimedia integrator and designer based in Montreal, Canada. El Nstic est en un moment durssim. They say they didnt, due to lack of time. Joel also works closely with collaborators in the ShowStages collective, which focuses on designing and implementing video narratives for the theatre. She talked about how English has gender and others, like my language, Farsi, is a genderless language, Ghodsi says. Then in September 2017, mass protests erupted on the University of California, Berkeley when former Breitbart editor Milo Yiannopoulos spoke on campus, albeit only a few words before he was reportedly whisked away to safety by police. Ker sodie ve kot oitno ne namerava obsoditi . Theyll think Ill release it to the media, she says. During the disciplinary interview, which Shepherd secretly taped, the professors likened an objective presentation of the Peterson debate to objectively presenting a speech by Adolf Hitler. Its a Friday afternoon in late November and Shepherd is sitting at Wilfs, a campus restaurant at Wilfrid Laurier University. He described Jordan Peterson as an alt-right figure and said his views are in violation of the Canadian human rights code. In a telephone interview withMacleans, Laurier student Vivek Ramesh answers questions as voices in the backgroundwho are never namedcan be heard whispering responses to him. She has had supporting roles in the films Pacific Rim Uprising (2018), Life of the Party (2018), Triple Frontier (2019), 6 Underground (2019) and Morbius (2022). Shepherd recorded her meeting with Joel, Pimlott and Rambukkana. She says there have been others standing patiently for a long time, and perhaps he can wait. Joel Adria joel@joeladria.com Joel Adria Multimedia Technician 2015 Portfolio Highlights WATERLOO, Ontario, January 2, 2019 (LifeSiteNews) The two Canadian university professors who bullied a teaching assistant to tears because she showed students a clip of a debate with Jordan Peterson have now mentioned her in a third party lawsuit. And how gender should maybe not be part of the language. There was also a debate on the public broadcaster TVOntario (TVO) where they talked about pronoun usage. I could see that this sort of thing was inevitable, but also built right into the legislation. The task force will develop a policy to balance academic freedom and freedom of speech with Lauriers vision mission and values by March 2018, according to the Star. There was no TV in the Shepherd home growing up. People can disagree with me., McEwin is standing towards the back of the crowd. He shot into the media spotlight after voicing his opposition to political correctness and Canadas Bill C-16. Shepherd talks to every media outlet that asks her. I dont subscribe to the wasteful consumerist culture that we live in and I didnt want my children to watch all the advertising, says Jennifer Shepherd, Lindsays mom and a school teacher in Coquitlam, B.C. Front Royal, VA 22630, 157 Catharine St N, Unit 2 Practice their speeches. Looking for Joel Adria? If you find yourself aligning with any of those folks, you can move along, nothing to see here. Its early December and a professor in one of Shepherds courses asks her to put away her laptop. Rambukkana admitted Shepherd is right to say that making a space for controversial or oppositional views is important, and even essential to a university., The President and Vice-Chancellor of the University also made apologies. Adria Joel, MSW, RSW Group and Workshop Coordinator at Sexual Assault Support Centre of Waterloo Region Kitchener, Ontario, Canada 113 followers 110 connections Join to connect Sexual Assault. She walked 30 minutes with heavy bags full of bottles just to make sure she could recycle them properly., At one point, Ghodsi threw out the suggestion that, in the interest of saving time and getting to hang out a bit more togetherand just this oncethey throw everything in the garbage. Williams also wrote an open letter to Lauriers president, Deborah MacLatchy, saying trans people deserve an apology from her and Nathan Rambukkana, the communications studies professor and Shepherds TA supervisor, for failing to acknowledge trans-related violence in either of their apology letters to Shepherd. In November 2017, Shepherd played her communications class two clips of a debate, formerly aired on Canadian public broadcaster TVOntario, with . The first clip, which runs less than two minutes, starts at the 4:45 mark when Jordan Peterson, a psychology professor at the University of Toronto, is asked what he finds so offensive about Bill C-16, the proposed legislation (later passed in Parliament) that added gender expression and identity to grounds for discrimination under the Canadian Human Rights Act. On our crest, it saysVeritas Omnia Vincit, which means truth conquers all. But how can truth win a battle if one side cant competeif one side gets censored?. We reject efforts of those who have seized this episode as a strategic opportunity to disparage disciplines and scholars with commitments to improving social and economic equality within universities and in society at large, the letter said. Theres no being happy about that., He knew Shepherds story was coming, though. Re: those claiming I have a right-wing agenda: Unfortunately, you have missed the point. She wants a salad, but then she looks at the clock. Laurier TAs mostly had autonomy in deciding lesson plans to make things interesting. Wilfrid Laurier University, Fire Nathan Rambukkana and Adria Joel, Copyright 2023 Care2.com, inc. and its licensors. If you are interested in this . Previously, Adria was a Research Assistant at Wilfrid Laurier University and also held positions at Family & Children's Services of Guelph and Wellington County, YWCA Kitchener Waterloo, University of Guelph, L'Arche Canada. Shepherd explains the situation. Telling them that? The second clip, almost three minutes long, starts more than 49 minutes into the segment when Paikin speaks with Nicholas Matte, a historian who teaches in the Sexual Diversity Studies program at the University of Toronto. As such, the counter-protesters hold placards around their shirts that read Trans People Deserve Justice. Many of them keep their faces covered under a scarf. To call this scandalous is barely to scratch the surface, he wrote. How many? I introduced it critically, Like I said, it was in the spirit of debate., But that wasnt good enough for Rambukkana, who said Shepherd should have presented Petersons view as a problematic idea that we want to unpack.. Shepherd finds herself at the epicenter of a debate that has erupted at universities, in online chatrooms and newspaper editorials across the continent; where Laurier has been pulled into disrepute and its academics brought to the edge of paranoia. Josh Leibold did sit in her classShepherds first of three that day. Campus is quiet. A RECORDING has been leaked of a teaching assistant being interrogated for presenting both sides of the debate over gender pronouns. The day prior, the campus newspaper The Cordwhose cover story was of Lindsay Shepherd making national headlines, and featured a letter to the editor from Toby Finlay talking about how debates of the validity of trans people create an unsafe campus environmentwere ripped at multiple newsstands. The online headline read: Thought police strike again as Wilfrid Laurier grad student is chastised for showing Jordan Peterson video. As the story gained national attention, Shepherd released the audio to multiple media outlets so everyone could hear what happened in that room. There is this misconception that free speech is a conservative issue, but thats not the case, says Alexander Eyre, president of the University of Waterloo Conservatives. Shepherd agreed, and was greeted at the meeting by Rambukkana, Pimlott and Adria Joel, the acting manager for gendered violence prevention and support at Laurier. Critics have warned that under Bill C-16, Canadians who deny gender theory could be charged with hate crimes, fined, jailed, and compelled to undergo anti-bias training. Features a high-level of standard equipment, with a manual only 6-speed gearbox and the benefits of a large 90l fuel tank. Rambukkana also suggested that by not taking sides, Shepherd was targeting someone due to their gender identity or gender expression and so could be breaking Bill C-16 and violating the Ontario Human Rights Code. You have JavaScript disabled. The debate involved Petersons resistance to the enforced use of pronouns in vogue with transgender activists. A reporter asks if they extended the invitation to the Rainbow Centre. That also in a huge way makes me feel fairly unsafe on campus because I dont know who might recognize me and approach me out of nowhere and have something violent to say or do, Hewson says. WATERLOO, Ontario, November 20, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) Communications student Lindsay Shepherd has committed a thought crime: she presented students with opposed points of view in an evenhanded fashion. The problem I had with it was he was shutting down the conversation right away, Shepherd says. Shes uncomfortable having their support.. Shepherds supervisor, Nathan Rambukkana, asked if she could come in for a meeting the next day at 2:30pm in his office where the head of her program, Herbert Pimlott, and someone for the diversity and equity office who would also be in attendance. As the Shepherd story gained traction in the media, Peterson read as columnists said that my views were abhorrent, he says, including two inMacleansthat were most egregious., Those contentious views regarding the use of gender pronouns are explained in a YouTube video Peterson posted in 2016 about the Ontario Human Rights Commissions definition of gender identityas each persons internal and individual experience of gender. I sound very reasonable with what I said. Peterson, one of the debaters, is a tenured professor of Psychology at the University of Toronto. The video was showed and she asked the class for some of their thoughts. As counter-protesters leave as a group, Shepherd waits patiently as fansmostly young menqueue up for a chance to exchange a few words with her, and maybe take a selfie. No one deserves that., Finn worries about Shepherd advocating for secretly recording meetings with professors, as she did on Twitter, and how she handed it to the media at the first sign of transgression. Adria Joel is on Facebook. Politicians have weighed in in too, such as federal Conservative leader Andrew Scheers campaign promise to deny federal funding to universities that dont allow free debate. [] I want people to be aware that trans and gender diverse communitiesand especially people of colourare being targeted and threatened physically. To speak to an individual as they., Peterson counters: Right. MacLatchey did not comment Monday if WLU will penalize Rambukkana, Joel and Pimlott. Shes been talking and listening for more than an hour. At least not on the record with the media. By telling them ideas that are really out there? 500 million . Robitaille was part of the team that successfully defended former CBC personality Jian Ghomeshi in his sexual assault trial. In the recorded audio, Rumbukkana objected to Shepherds decision to air Petersons problematic opinions. If theres something she doesnt believe in, she wont do it no matter what the cost.. Shepherds hectorers were lying to her, like cops trying to extract a confession from a suspect, and they knew they were lying to her, wrote University of Toronto political science professor Clifford Orwin in the Globe.
Still Alice Ending, Agrihoods In Virginia, Articles A