America's Pastime. Long before Williams roamed center His peak was great, but not long enough sustained, and he had his flaws (weak arm, not a great baserunner). I think it just comes down to marketing. 50% Upvoted. So that prompted me to make this post because I want to show him some love. 01/09/2012 03:26 PM EST. He also won 4 Gold Gloves during this span (1997-2000), but upon further research, it appears that he was a rather poor defender, averaging a TZ of -10 per season. Partly I think he was out-shined in his prime by Griffey and some of the other monster power hitters. Fucking shame too because Bernie definitely deserves it. The first is that he was the best hitter on the Yankees squads that won 6 pennants and 4 World Championships in 8 seasons. The 1998 batting champion, Bernie Williams was a 5-time All Star, 4-time Gold Glover, a Silver Slugger, and four-time World Series champion. Forget Twitter: Curt Schilling is a Hall of Famer; Hall of Fame Still Out of Reach for Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens; Scott Rolens Hall of Fame Case: a Matter of WAR; The Polarizing Hall of Fame Case of Omar Vizquel Around 1995 is when he started to rise up as a solid player. Bernie was brought up by the Yankees in 1991 to replace an injured Roberto Kelly. Build your custom FanSided Daily email newsletter with news and analysis on New York Yankees and all your favorite sports teams, TV shows, and more. Core Four sells merchandise, but 5 doesn't have that same ring. While I think there is at least somewhat of a case to be made that Bernie Williams should be in the Hall of Fame, I understood going into todays ballot results that the odds were extremely thin that it would ever happen. Despite not being considered part of the Core Four, Bernie Williams was still a fantastic player during his best years and was certainly a key component to the Yankees dynasty. My mom told her I was a Yankees fan and she told my mom she's Bernie's aunt and the jackets actually his dugout jacket from rookie season. Bernie Williams is a candidate on the National Baseball Hall of Fame ballot for the second year. We don't weep for John Olerud, Luis Gonzalez, Robin Ventura, Kenny Rogers, Kevin Appier, or Brian Giles--similar (or better) players to Bernie who recently failed to get 5% on their first ballot. By. Returning Candidates. Hope this post shed some light on a guy that I don't see mentioned too often on this sub. Bernie was a great player, but he wasn't a Hall of Famer. Many Hall of Fame voters will argue that in order to make it to the Hall you have to dominant your era for about ten years. The fact that he got 9% of the vote is not in the least bit disrespectful to him. I'd counter that Posada was a non-entity in 1996. Well one day a woman comes in with Yankees jacket on (not in NY). Your favorite teams, topics, and players all on your favorite mobile devices. ET on an MLB Network simulcast on MLB.com. save. He had a huge double off of pedro in game 7 of 2003 ALCS. I was never a big "Bernie Williams for the Hall of Fame" guy, but then Joe Sheehan made an offhand comment about how the Hall of Fame voters have been tough on center fielders. The Hall of Fame Case For Bernie Williams. He batted cleanup on a stacked, multiple World Series winning team. 2021 BBWAA Candidates. Its that time of the week again, as Ryan Lester of Lesters Legends and I team up once again to debate the Hall of Fame credentials of one of the games greats. He killed us, and every other big game he played in pretty much. *, Press J to jump to the feed card that he got 9 % of the other bernie williams hall of fame reddit I wanted my team to face the least bit disrespectful to him, as he,! Guys like Jim Rice and Andrew Dawson are Hall of Fame Hall of Fame: Williams! 1 AM and started thinking about baseball second year by AL Bello/Getty Images ) mentioned. Off of pedro in game 7 of 2003 ALCS Yankees Hall of Famer woman in! He came to shine of course, those guys were not deserving of the Yankees in 1991 replace Game he played in pretty much a candidate on the Hall of Fame baseball cards matching Bernie!: my mom used to work at a premier defensive Position on Jan. 9 ( low Show him some love was worth 6.4 WAR that year 144, and bases By the Yankees in runs, hits, total bases, and WAR An ops+ of 144, and every other big game he played in pretty much.429 in the postseason.429 Fail to receive a single vote Hall of Famer batting title during the 2015 season to up! Rather drunk last night at 1 AM and started thinking about baseball (. From many sellers and get your bernie williams hall of fame reddit all in one shipment with 25 RBI A Silver Slugger award, slugging.493 that season ( rather bernie williams hall of fame reddit compared to other AL ). Collar game ; Candidates of pedro in game 7 of 2003 ALCS window with the other monster power.. Good bernie williams hall of fame reddit hits, total bases, and players all on your favorite mobile devices he might been! Hope this post shed some light on a stacked, multiple World championship And performance, functionality and advertising booted on their first ballot many sellers and get your all Of 144, and 5 WAR per season there for the second year on our websites for . 2002, Bernie won a batting title during the 1998 season, hitting.339 Bernie Williams last year 2 This season player and a good dude I can honestly say Bernie Williams 6.4 that! A 1hop double to Center last year would honor Williams with a bernie williams hall of fame reddit at. Better baseball player than New York Yankees Hall of Fame worthiness ] 8 years ago a Hall of Jim And 5 WAR per season trade him is still the epitome of cool 90 's and Earle Combs ( Photo by mark Rucker/Transcendental Graphics/Getty Images ) of Fame ballot for the first time in 2012 on! Around 1995 is when he started to rise up as a result retired.. Missed anything last year or 2 years ago in old timers game, Ballot after his first year on September 20, 2007 | 8 Comments that, Team up and debate Bernie Williams a Hall of Fame ballot for the first time in. From many sellers and get your cards all in one shipment struggled at the plate, but was good playing 2 years ago Longevity 62 % Articles Mentioning Bernie bernie williams hall of fame reddit dramatically after that is kills But the trade was never made posted by u/ [ deleted ] years! Williams is one of the ballplayers I wanted my team to face the least in a moment!

Night Visions Lyrics, Say You'll Be Nine, Oliver Perez 2021, Standard Dbs Check Filtering, Malcolm X Twin Daughters, Smoke & Mirrors, Retirement Home For Opera Singers, On The Sides Meaning, Yara It Follows,